Why the Ukraine War Is Working for Putin

The conflict has solidified his hold over Russia while dividing Europe.

Nov. 16, 2026 5:38 pm 
Opinion
Original article contains several links


Vladimir Putin in Moscow, Nov. 16. Alexander Kazakov/Sputnik/Pool/Associated Press

As Vladimir Putin repeatedly brushes aside President Trump’s efforts to broker peace in Ukraine, the White House needs to ask a basic question: Why is Mr. Putin so committed to the war in Ukraine?

Russia’s costly ground war is failing. The conflict exposes Moscow’s overstretched and underperforming economy to damaging strains. The opportunity costs are steep. Focusing so many resources on the Ukraine war left the Kremlin short of the resources needed to protect its positions in places like Armenia and Syria.

Seeing those facts, many analysts, including your faithful Global View columnist, have written repeated think pieces on why the invasion of Ukraine was a dangerous strategic blunder by the Russian president. Yet journalists’ crystalline logic and persuasive prose haven’t shaken Mr. Putin’s resolve. He appears determined to fight on.

There seem to be two reasons for his persistence. The first is that whatever else Mr. Putin may be, he isn’t a babbling fool. Even if he thought he needed to end the war quickly, he would hang tough in public. Showing any weakness, irresolution or distress would only encourage the Ukrainians to hold out for better terms while weakening his position at home.

The second reason is that he may believe that the horrific costs of the war are at least partially offset by the benefits it brings. The war has helped Mr. Putin to solidify his hold over Russia, marginalize his political opponents, and reorient the economy around the needs of Russia’s military machine. It has forced the sluggish Russian military to adapt to the 21st century and develop the technologies and the industrial base it will need to stay relevant as a new revolution in military affairs upends the global status quo.

Seen from the Kremlin, Ukraine may be performing unexpectedly well on the battlefield, but on the international level Russia is winning the war. Moscow’s partnerships with North Korea and China are becoming more effective the longer the war lasts, while the democratic alliance behind Ukraine shows signs of war-weariness and division. Better still, Mr. Putin may well believe, is the effect of the war on the prestige and the power of the trans-Atlantic alliance. Germany may be spending more on defense, but the Kremlin looks at Chancellor Friedrich Merz’s anemic poll numbers and thinks it has little to fear. A pro-Russian candidate seems poised to win France’s presidential election next spring, and the languid European Union and North Atlantic Treaty Organization responses to escalating Russian provocations confirm Mr. Putin’s belief that Europe’s political class is as divided and feckless as ever.

The effect of Russia’s appalling battlefield casualties on Kremlin calculations has so far been much weaker than Westerners hope. If Mr. Putin truly cannot stand the level of casualties, he always has the option of pausing his sputtering and expensive ground offensive while intensifying the air war. That he has chosen to continue with the bloody ground campaign suggests either that he considers the losses sustainable or that he believes Ukraine’s limited manpower is less able to withstand the current level of combat. He probably also believes that continuing the ground offensive forces Russia’s generals to stay focused on the changes required to wage war effectively in the 21st century.

Additionally, Mr. Putin is likely satisfied with the state of the air war. Ukraine’s dramatic strikes against Russian oil and commercial facilities are damaging and embarrassing, but so far they haven’t threatened Moscow’s ability to continue the war. Russia’s strikes on Ukraine appear more consequential, attacking the energy and water infrastructure Ukraine’s economy and citizens need to get through the winter. Ukrainians worry that long power and heat outages during the winter will force many to flee west, further weakening the struggling economy. Successful missile strikes against vital urban infrastructure could also force Ukraine to concentrate its limited defensive weaponry on cities rather than on troops at the front.

Mr. Putin presumably knows that at some point the costs of the war to Russia, already substantial and damaging, could become too great to bear. But for now, he remains hopeful that time is on his side. And if victory over Ukraine divides and undermines the Western alliance system, the war’s benefits from his point of view would justify the costs.

There are, still, ways that a united West could change the Kremlin’s calculations. But Moscow increasingly and perhaps rationally is discounting that possibility. Rhetoric about democracy, sovereignty, territorial integrity and human rights, yes. The clear thinking and focused action that would force the Russian president to rethink his war? Not yet.

Until that changes, it is difficult to see Mr. Putin changing course, no matter what tempting off-ramps Mr. Trump and his colleagues offer.

***

Walter Russell Mead is the Ravenel B. Curry III Distinguished Fellow in Strategy and Statesmanship at Hudson Institute, the Global View Columnist at The Wall Street Journal and the Alexander Hamilton Professor of Strategy and Statecraft with the Hamilton School for Classical and Civic Education at the University of Florida. 

He is also a member of Aspen Institute Italy and board member of Aspenia. Before joining Hudson, Mr. Mead was a fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations as the Henry A. Kissinger Senior Fellow for U.S. Foreign Policy. He has authored numerous books, including the widely-recognized Special Providence: American Foreign Policy and How It Changed the World (Alfred A. Knopf, 2004). Mr. Mead’s most recent book is titled The Arc of A Covenant: The United States, Israel, and the Fate of the Jewish People.

***

The above article contains a film: Global View columnist Walter Russell Mead joins the show to unpack the larger thinking behind Trump's latest flurry of diplomacy. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

As Ukraine Raises Alarm Over U.S. Backing, Europeans Pledge Support

The Ukrainian Attacks That Are Forcing Russia to Ration Its Fuel